What is wrong with either of them? DI is a copycat of the GoW formula but well executed and GoW III is one of the best Hack 'n Slash titles ever created. A game - as with every other entertainment media - has to do WHAT it does well. Personal taste is a triviality when discussing overall quality, preferences have no claim on such a debate. Deus Ex was almost perfect in every regard for the time it came out and is still much bolder than your average "politically correct" title even after all these years. These are simple facts.