I say renew, just because this place is a daily part of internet life for me. It's not that active, but I still check it daily. Of course, i'm not the one stuck with paying for the hosting and domain, so...
Renew, but like Logan said you're the one who pays the bills. I still come here everyday, even though it's been practically inactive for the past 6 months or so. If you still have plans to improve the site (as in making it a fansite or something), I say definitely renew it. If not, it's your call.
Unless you have plans to give this site a theme (this was more active when it was Zelda, and the thought of a Final Fantasy theme hear was brought up) It is entirely your call, even though I've been here for two years.
Edit: And if you do decide on expire, I think we should all migrate to another message board.
If it were up to me, it'd be renew, as already said, this is a daily part of my online life. I think we should all try to come up with a good theme for this place, like maybe Halo 2 or something.
I knew this was going to come up soon. It's only a matter of time. As much as I enjoy this forum I guess all good things must come to an end. If it does close down I agree that we should arrange a place for XF members to migrate to. Hopefully someplace small... I don't like the gigantic-ness (umm...) of big forums like Penny Arcade or GameFAQs or Allakhazam or whatever.
Well We need to hear what decision Travis has come to, because we don't have much time left and if he isn't renewing we need to think of a place to migrate to.
Final Fantasy is already well established on the internet. It'd be hard, if not impossible to establish a site that was different from the others, which is why I have not actively pursued this idea.